top of page

Why Shopify is Great for Handmade Sellers and Artists: A Deep Dive

Updated: Oct 5, 2023

Are you starting your online selling journey, or already selling online and thinking of switching platforms? The first big question is: Where should I set up shop? This decision is a crucial one and can significantly impact your selling journey. Often, artists and handmade sellers gravitate towards platforms like Etsy or eBay. They're popular and have a built-in audience, but they also come with certain limitations.

Why Shopify is great for Handmade Sellers and Artists: A Deep Dive I Your Guide Online

What's in this blog?

The Common Paths: Etsy and eBay

Etsy and eBay are like bustling market halls. They draw a crowd, but it's easy to get lost in the sea of sellers. Plus, they come with their own set of rules and fees, which might not always work in your favour.

A Fresh Alternative: Shopify

And then there's Shopify - it's like having your own boutique in the digital world. Unlike Etsy and eBay, Shopify gives you the tools to create a space that reflects your brand. It's simple to use, and you don't need to be a tech wizard to get started.

In this post, we'll explore why Shopify is a fantastic choice for artists and handmade sellers, whether you're just beginning or considering a move from other platforms. *Disclaimer: This post is NOT sponsored by Shopify or any other entity, but we are huge fans of Shopify, so sit back, and let us tell you why!

Ease of Setting Up a Shop on Shopify

Starting your online shop should be exciting, not stressful. Shopify keeps it simple so you can focus on what you do best: creating amazing items. Let’s break down how:

User-friendly Interface

Shopify’s interface is clean and intuitive. Even if you’re new to the digital scene, you’ll find your way around quickly. Setting up your shop is a straightforward process: name your shop, add products, set up payment methods, and you’re ready to go!

Pre-designed Templates Catered to Artistic Niches

Shopify gets that artists and handmade sellers have a unique vibe. They offer a variety of pre-designed templates that can make your shop look professional and inviting without complicated coding or technical skills. These templates are like empty galleries waiting for your art. And the best part? Many of them are free!

Initial Cost and Basic Technical Requirements

Worried about costs? Shopify has a range of pricing plans to fit different budgets. The basic plan is affordable and includes all the essential features you need to start selling. As for tech requirements, you don’t need to be a tech guru. If you can use a smartphone comfortably, you can set up a Shopify store. Plus, there’s a lot of helpful guides, 24 hour telephone and online support, and a supportive community to help you if you get stuck.

Customisability and Branding

Your brand is your story, and telling it right is crucial for connecting with customers. Let’s dive into how Shopify helps you do just that.

The Importance of Branding

For artists and handmade sellers, your brand is often a reflection of you. It's about more than just a logo or a catchy name; it's about creating a unique world that your customers can step into. Effective branding helps you stand out, tells your story, and attracts the right crowd.

Personalised Storefront with Shopify

Shopify allows you to design your store’s look from scratch. You can choose colours, layouts, and styles that match your brand's vibe. It’s about creating a unique space that resonates with your audience and makes them want to stay and explore.

Shopify vs Etsy and eBay: Branding Opportunities

On Etsy and eBay, you're a part of a larger marketplace. Your store has some simple customisations, but generally has to fit the platforms style and looks like every other store, with only a small space for your branding. It’s easy to get lost in the crowd.

On the flip side, Shopify is your own little corner on the internet. Here, every detail can scream ‘you’, from the storefront design to the way you interact with your customers. It's about standing out, not blending in.

Control Over Pricing and Policies

When it comes to selling online, having control over your pricing and policies is crucial. It's about fairness to you and clarity for your customers. Here’s how Shopify stands out:

Set Your Own Prices

On platforms like Etsy or eBay, you might find yourself entangled in a web of fees and pricing competitions. With your competitors' work placed right next to yours, It can feel like a tug-of-war, pulling your prices in directions you’re not comfortable with.

Shopify gives you the reins. You decide the price tag based on what’s fair for your time, effort, and creativity. No outside pressures, no unexpected fee surprises. It’s your work, your price.

Your Policies, Your Way

Every artist and seller has their own way of managing returns and shipping. Maybe you offer no-questions-asked returns, or perhaps you have specific shipping options based on your products.

Shopify lets you set up policies that work for you. It’s a straightforward process to outline your shipping, return, and other policies. Clear policies make for happy customers, and happy customers come back.

Independence from Platform Algorithm Changes

Online marketplaces are known for their ever-changing algorithms, which can sometimes feel like shifting sands under your feet. Let’s look at how Shopify offers a more stable ground:

The Algorithm Rollercoaster on Etsy and eBay

Selling on Etsy or eBay? You might have noticed your store's visibility going up and down. That’s often due to algorithm changes. These platforms tweak their algorithms to decide which products get seen, and staying on top of these changes can feel like a full-time job.

Steady Ground with Shopify

Switch to Shopify, and the ground stops shaking. Here, your shop’s visibility isn’t at the mercy of a changing algorithm. Instead, it's about how well you connect with your audience and how effectively you market your shop. It's stable, predictable, and all in your hands. Yes, it's hard work building your own audience, but you own your data and the customer base you build is solid. No more worrying about waking up to an algorithm change that's swept your shop under the rug. It's about building a real foundation for your online business that lasts, one where your hard work defines your success, not an unpredictable algorithm.

Marketing and SEO Capabilities

Getting your beautiful creations in front of the right eyes is crucial. Shopify provides a toolbox full of marketing and SEO goodies to help you do just that. Let’s delve into some of these features:

SEO Features

Shopify is built with SEO in mind to help your shop climb the ranks of search engine results. With simple tools to edit your title tags, meta descriptions, and URLs, you're well on your way to becoming an SEO pro.

Mastering SEO for E-Commerce Guide I Your Guide Online

And for a deeper dive into mastering SEO, our Mastering SEO for E-commerce guide is a treasure trove of tips and strategies.

Social Media Integration

Connecting your shop with social media platforms easily with Shopify. With just a few clicks, you can integrate your store with platforms like Facebook and Instagram, turning your social media profiles into additional storefronts.

Email Marketing Capabilities

Email marketing is crucial for building and nurture relationships with your customers. With your own website, you own your customer data and can build an opt-in email marketing list. Shopify has built-in email marketing features that let you create, run, and track email campaigns. Whether it’s announcing a new collection or sharing a special discount, email is a direct line to your audience that’s always in style.

With Shopify’s marketing and SEO capabilities, spreading the word about your shop and drawing in the right crowd is less about guesswork and more about following proven steps towards success.

Transaction Fees and Financial Considerations

When it comes to selling online, every penny counts. Let’s compare the transaction fees and pricing plans to see how Shopify stacks up against Etsy and eBay.

Transaction Fees: Shopify vs Etsy vs eBay

Every platform has its cost. Etsy and eBay take a slice of your sales through listing fees and transaction fees. Over time, these slices can add up, eating into your profits.

On the other hand, Shopify has a clear transaction fee structure. You pay a monthly fee for your online storefront, and a small fee for each transaction. It’s straightforward and predictable, which is great for planning your finances.

Here is a comparison table for Shopify, Etsy & Ebay Fees 2023:

Fee Type




Listing Fee


​£0.20 per listing​

Free; £0.35 per listing if more than 250 listings per month

Transaction Fee

Varies: 2.4% + £0.30 to 2.9% + £0.30 based on plan​

6.5% (5% of the item price + shipping)

Varies: 2.5% to 15% based on factors​

Payment Processing Fee

Included in Transaction Fee



Monthly Fee

£5 to £2,000 based on plan​

Optional £10 for Etsy-backed website​


Currency Conversion Fee




Ad Fees


Etsy Ads Fees​ (variable)

​eBay Ads Fees (variable)

Other Fees



Final Value Fee, Insertion Fee​

  • Shopify:

    • Monthly fees vary greatly depending on the chosen plan.

    • Transaction fees also vary slightly based on the plan.

    • There's no listing fee, and the payment processing fee is included in the transaction fee.

  • Etsy:

    • Has a listing fee and a transaction fee.

    • A currency conversion fee is applicable.

    • Etsy also offers an optional monthly fee for an Etsy-backed website.

    • There are additional Etsy Ads fees.

  • eBay:

    • Listing is free up to 250 listings, beyond which a fee is charged.

    • Transaction fees range based on a multitude of factors.

    • eBay also charges a final value fee and an insertion fee.

    • There are additional eBay Ads fees.

Shopify’s Pricing Plans

Shopify offers different pricing plans to fit various needs and budgets. The basic plan provides all the essentials to get your shop up and running. As your business grows, you can upgrade to plans with more features to help you scale.

Community and Support

Entering the online selling world can feel like stepping into a vast unknown. Let’s look at the support available:

Shopify’s Community Forums and Support Channels

Got a question or hit a snag? Shopify’s community forums are bustling with sellers just like you. It's a place to share experiences, ask questions, and find answers. And if you need direct help, Shopify’s support channels are available 24/7 by phone or online chat. Whether it's a late-night query or an early morning hiccup, help is just a click away.

Resources and Guides for Newcomers

New to online selling or migrating from another platform? Shopify has a heap of resources to smooth your path. From step-by-step guides to tutorials, there’s a lot to help you set up shop, manage your store, and start making sales.

Plus, with our helpful resources like Transitioning from Marketplaces to Your Own Website, the transition to Shopify is made easier. With a supportive community and a host of resources, Shopify ensures you have the help and information you need to navigate the online selling world with confidence.

Success Stories

Nothing speaks louder than the triumphs of those who have walked the path. Let’s peek into the real-world journeys of two of our clients; artists and handmade sellers who have found their stride on Shopify.

Thriving Artists and Handmade Sellers on Shopify

Jasneet is a jewelry designer who moved from Etsy to Shopify. She wanted a unique space to tell her story and showcase her creations. Now, with her own Shopify store, she enjoys the freedom to brand her store just the way sh

e likes, leading to a loyal customer base and increased sales. She still has her Etsy store, but the majority of her business now comes directly through her own Shopify website.

Then there’s Elliot, a potter who started his online selling journey on Shopify. With the easy-to-use tools, he set up his store over a weekend and started selling his pottery online. The simple yet powerful marketing tools helped him reach and grow his audience, turning his passion into a profitable business. He also runs a local weekly pottery class and uses Shopify to book, promote and manage his classes.

These stories echo across the Shopify community, with millions of sellers who have created a thriving space where your creativity drives your success.

Transitioning from Other Platforms

Moving your shop might seem like a big leap, but with the right guidance and tools, it can be an exciting progression. Let’s explore how you can transition from Etsy or eBay to Shopify with ease:

Guide to Moving Your Shop

Transitioning can be streamlined with the right steps. The Transitioning from Marketplaces to Your Own Website guide is your roadmap. It walks you through the process, ensuring you have a well-laid plan to move your shop without missing a beat.

Transitioning from Marketplaces to your own website I Your Guide Online

Tools and Services for a Smooth Transition

There are tools and services designed to make your move to Shopify simple. For instance, apps like "Etsy to Shopify" or "eBay to Shopify" can help transfer your listings. Plus, Shopify’s support community is always ready to lend a helping hand, ensuring you have the support you need to transition smoothly.

With the right guide and tools, transitioning to Shopify can be a step towards more control and growth for your online business.

Building Your Own Website

Creating a website is like crafting a digital home for your business. It's where your brand comes to life and where customers come to explore. Let’s look at how you can build a solid online presence with Shopify:

Overview of Your Guide: Building Your Own Website

The Building Your Own Website: A Comprehensive Guide for Online Businesses is your companion in this digital construction project. It walks you through the essentials, from choosing a catchy domain name to designing a user-friendly layout that keeps customers engaged.

Establishing a Solid Online Presence with Shopify

This guide is packed with actionable steps to help you create a standout Shopify store. It covers the basics and beyond, ensuring you have a clear path to follow. With the guide by your side, setting up your Shopify store becomes a well-guided adventure, not a daunting task.

By following the guide, you'll be well on your way to establishing a solid online presence. It's about creating a space that not only looks great but also works seamlessly to provide a delightful shopping experience for your customers.

Targeting the Right Audience

Finding and connecting with the right audience is like setting up a successful date between your creations and those who’ll cherish them. Let’s delve into how you can ensure this match-making success:

Your Guide to Finding Customers

The Finding Your Customers: Targeting and Reaching the Right Audience Online guide is your playbook. It offers insights and actionable steps to identify and reach the folks who are most likely to fall in love with your products.

Understanding Your Audience: The Key to Online Success

Knowing your audience is like having a map in the digital wilderness. It guides your marketing efforts, helping you speak the language of your potential customers. Shopify provides tools to gather insights about your visitors, allowing you to tailor your approach to match their preferences.

With the right guidance and a deeper understanding of your audience, your online shop becomes a meeting ground where your creations and the right audience come together. It’s about building relationships, not just making sales.

Considerations Before Choosing Shopify

We want to offer balance in this article to help you make the right decsion. While we are big fans of Shopify, and it's a robust and user-friendly platform, it's essential to consider a few aspects before making a decision:

Monthly Fees

Unlike Etsy and eBay, where you pay per listing, Shopify charges a monthly fee. Ensure that this subscription model fits within your budget, especially if you are just starting out.

Transaction Fees

While Shopify's transaction fees are competitive, they still exist. If you choose to use a payment provider other than Shopify Payments, additional transaction fees may apply.

Customisation Learning Curve

Although Shopify offers a range of pre-designed templates, if you wish for a highly customized store, there might be a learning curve, or you might need to hire a professional.

SEO Competitiveness

While Shopify provides SEO tools, standing out in search engine rankings is competitive. It requires a consistent effort and possibly additional SEO optimisation knowledge or resources.

App Integrations

While Shopify has a wide range of app integrations, not every third-party app or tool you might want to use will integrate seamlessly. Ensure the essential tools you need are compatible with Shopify.

Considering these factors alongside the benefits will help you make an informed decision on whether Shopify is the right platform for your online business venture.

Embarking on the online selling journey or looking for a fresh start, the platform you choose is your partner in this adventure. Shopify emerges as a friendly and empowering companion for handmade sellers and artists.

Your Turn to Explore Shopify

Each platform has its own vibe, but Shopify’s blend of simplicity, control, and support makes it a standout choice. Whether you are just starting out or thinking of moving from Etsy or eBay, exploring Shopify could be the next big step towards turning your creative passion into a thriving online venture.

So why not take a peek? Explore Shopify, dive into the resources, and envision the beautiful space you can create for your brand. With a bit of guidance and the right tools at your disposal, the digital world is a canvas waiting for your brush strokes.


About Your Guide Online

Your Guide Online is your go-to resource for Online Business Success. We offer tailored Guides, expert blogs, and essential Toolkit resources for StartUps, Small Businesses and Freelancers.

A collection of downloadable E-Guides for Business Success by Your Guide Online

Hungry for more insights? Whether you're looking for actionable guides to ramp up your online business strategy, or resources to understand the digital trends, we've got a treasure trove of information waiting for you.

  • Explore our Comprehensive Guides on mastering SEO, social media promotion, and more. Here’s a little gift to get you started: enjoy an exclusive 10% discount off any purchase with the code: YOURGUIDE10.

  • Dive into our Resource Hub for recommendations on tools and services to boost your online business.

  • Check out our ToolKit section for practical resources like checklists and tutorials that link to the topics discussed in our blogs and guides.

  • and don't forget to check out more of our Blog for news, tutorials, how-to guides and the latest insights into digital trends.

BONUS: Subscribe free here to receive a FREE Monthly Guide to online business success, exclusive discounts, news, and tutorials! We really do give you great value at no cost!


bottom of page