top of page

6 Top Etsy Algorithm Questions Answered: Insights for Shop Growth in 2024

Welcome to the world of Etsy, a place where your shop's success largely depends on how well you understand the site's search algorithm. For Etsy sellers, getting to grips with this algorithm is crucial. It’s what puts your products in front of buyers and, ultimately, drives your sales.

6 Top Etsy Algorithm Questions Answered Insights for Shop Growth in 2024 I Your Guide Online

In 2024, just like in previous years, the Etsy algorithm will continue to evolve. This means that as a seller, you need to stay on top of these changes to keep your shop visible to potential customers. In this post, we'll answer six of the most common questions about the Etsy algorithm, giving you the insights you need to help your shop succeed in 2024 and beyond.

1: How Does the Etsy Algorithm Work?

Think of Etsy's algorithm as a helpful friend who knows what you like and recommends products you might want to buy. It sorts through thousands of items to show shoppers the best matches based on what they've searched for, liked, or bought in the past.

Here’s how it does that:

  • Search Terms: It looks at the words people use to search and finds items with matching titles and tags.

  • Buyer Behaviour: It watches what shoppers do – like which items they spend time on and what they save or purchase.

  • Shop Quality: It checks how well your shop is doing, based on reviews and how happy your customers are.

This personal touch means every shopper sees something different, tailored just for them. But Etsy is always changing how it decides this, to make sure everyone has the best chance of finding something they love.

Dealing with Etsy Algorithm Updates Downloadable Guide I 6 Top Etsy Algorithm Questions Answered Insights for Shop Growth in 2024 I Your Guide Online

For sellers, these updates can be game-changers. That's why understanding the latest changes is crucial. Our guide "Dealing with Etsy Algorithm Updates" is a great place to start. It's packed with current information to help your shop get noticed and keep up with Etsy's changes.

Additionally, the algorithm considers other factors like how complete your listings are, how competitive your pricing is, and even the shipping options you offer.

Keeping your listings up-to-date, priced right, and with attractive shipping choices can help your items climb higher in search results.

2: Do More Sales Boost Item Visibility?

In the Etsy marketplace, it's commonly thought that the more sales you have, the more visible your items will be. There's truth to this, as Etsy's algorithm includes a 'Listing Quality Score'. This score rises when your items sell, which can boost their visibility in search results.

Here's what goes into the Listing Quality Score:

  • Sales History: Each sale gives your item a little boost, suggesting it's popular with customers.

  • Click-through Rate: If people click on your listing often, Etsy sees it as appealing and gives it a higher score.

  • Conversion Rate: When your clicks turn into purchases, that's a good sign to Etsy that your item is desirable.

Remember, a sudden drop in sales can be worrying, but it’s not always due to your visibility on Etsy. For a deeper understanding of sales trends, especially if you're concerned that your sales are lower than usual, have a read of our blog post "Why Your Etsy Shop Isn’t Selling and How to Fix It", which has lots of useful information. It provides insights that could explain why your sales are fluctuating and offers tips on how to address it.

Why Your Etsy Shop Isn’t Selling and How to Fix It Blog Post I 6 Top Etsy Algorithm Questions Answered Insights for Shop Growth in 2024 I Your Guide Online

Keep in mind that while sales can improve visibility, they're part of a larger picture. High-quality listings, good customer service, and keeping up with Etsy's SEO are all essential for maintaining and improving your Listing Quality Score.

3: How Does Customer Service Influence the Etsy Algorithm?

Does the way you handle customer service affect your shop's standing with the Etsy algorithm? Absolutely. Every interaction, from how you manage claims and messages to the way you process refunds and earn reviews, can impact your visibility.

Positive reviews and quick, helpful message responses tell Etsy that you're a trustworthy seller. This can lead to better search rankings. But too many claims or refunds might make Etsy think there's a problem with your shop, which could hurt your rankings.

In addressing how customer service factors such as Etsy seller score, Star Seller status, and Review Ratings affect a shop's ranking on the platform, it's important to understand that Etsy's algorithm is designed to promote a quality customer experience and marketplace trust.

Here's how each element plays into the algorithm:

Etsy Seller Score and Star Seller Program: The Star Seller program is a metric system Etsy uses to recognise sellers who consistently provide excellent customer service. To become a Star Seller, a shop must meet certain criteria involving message response rates, shipping times, and customer ratings over a three-month period​​. The requirements are centered around responding quickly to messages, shipping on time, and maintaining a high standard of 5-star ratings​​. Star Seller status is evaluated monthly, and Etsy considers the shop's data from the previous three months​​. This status can directly influence a shop's visibility since it contributes to the 'listing quality score', which is a known search ranking factor on Etsy​​.

Etsy Star Seller Criteria: The criteria for the Star Seller program include:

  1. Message Response Rate: Sellers should respond to messages within 24 hours from receipt of the first message​​.

  2. Shipping Timeliness: Orders should be shipped on time as promised in the listing.

  3. 5-Star Ratings: Maintaining a high number of 5-star reviews is crucial​​.

Etsy Review Ratings: Review ratings are a major ranking factor in the Etsy search algorithm. Shops with multiple 5-star reviews are likely to see a boost in their rankings within Etsy search results​​. Positive reviews serve as social proof to prospective buyers, demonstrating the trustworthiness and quality of the shop​​. Etsy's search results are personalised for each buyer, and listings with a high number of good reviews are more likely to be shown to potential buyers, thus improving a listing's visibility and potentially its sales conversion rate​.

Meeting these criteria is essential for sellers aiming to achieve and maintain Star Seller recognition, which can enhance their visibility on Etsy due to a higher listing quality score​. It is also noted that an occasional less-than-perfect review is not something that should be overly concerning​​.

A top-notch customer service strategy that yields positive reviews can elevate your shop in search results. Conversely, poor customer service could lower your visibility. For tips on handling the inevitable negative review with professionalism, "Responding to Bad Reviews: How ChatGPT Can Help Keep Your Cool" provides valuable advice. By maintaining excellent customer service, you not only please your buyers but also align with the Etsy algorithm's favour.

Responding to Bad Reviews: How ChatGPT Can Help Keep Your Cool Blog Post I 6 Top Etsy Algorithm Questions Answered Insights for Shop Growth in 2024 I Your Guide Online

In summary, Etsy's algorithm uses these customer service-related metrics to ensure that sellers who are providing an excellent customer experience are more visible and thus more likely to be successful on the platform. Sellers who prioritise customer satisfaction and strive to meet the criteria for the Star Seller program are likely to see an improvement in their shop's ranking within the Etsy search algorithm.

4: How Do Listings Quantity and Advertisements Affect the Etsy Algorithm?

When you're selling on Etsy, you might wonder if there's a secret recipe for gaining more visibility. Does it help to have a vast inventory or to put money behind ads?

Here's the scoop; it all comes down to visibility and relevancy.

  • Inventory Size: More items mean more opportunities to be discovered. Each listing can target different keywords, which helps in covering a broad spectrum of searches. This could lead to higher relevancy and click-through rates, which are positive signals to the algorithm because it suggests buyers find your items appealing.

  • Advertisements: While ads can temporarily elevate your listings to prime spots, giving them immediate visibility, this boost is usually short-lived. Once the ads are turned off, your listings might return to their previous positions unless the increased visibility has led to improved sales and reviews, which can have a longer-lasting positive effect on your ranking.

Etsy's machine learning models also consider the visual appeal of your listings. Clear, high-quality images can enhance the attractiveness of your products, thus affecting your search rankings positively. Meanwhile, using Etsy's paid ads can put your listings in more noticeable spots on search pages, increasing the likelihood of clicks and sales.

For tips on how to effectively increase your inventory and use ads without overspending, our Etsy Guide services offer personalised advice. They can help you navigate these aspects of the algorithm to boost your shop's performance.

Your Etsy Shop Guide Services I 6 Top Etsy Algorithm Questions Answered Insights for Shop Growth in 2024 I Your Guide Online

5: How Have Recent Changes Impacted the Etsy Algorithm?

The Etsy search landscape is never static, and in recent months it has seen its fair share of refinements. Understanding these shifts is key for sellers aiming to keep their listings visible and competitive.

Here’s what’s new and what you should focus on:

  1. Keyword Relevance: Etsy has honed in on keyword relevance, advocating for the use of specific and applicable keywords in titles, descriptions, and tags. The sharper your keyword game, the better your chances of ranking high in search results​​.

  2. Quality Imagery: High-quality photos are now more important than ever. Etsy's algorithm favors listings with images that are not only appealing but also reflective of the product's quality​​.

  3. Positive Feedback: Customer reviews have always mattered, but now they’re a bigger piece of the puzzle. Positive reviews can significantly boost your shop's visibility and trustworthiness​.

  4. Shop Optimisation: An organised and well-managed shop is a magnet for Etsy's algorithm. It's all about enhancing the shopper's experience from browsing to buying.

  5. Listing Quality and Conversion: The algorithm rewards listings with higher conversion rates, that is, views that turn into purchases. This factor underscores the importance of compelling product listings that encourage buyer engagement and sales​.

  6. Customer and Market Experience Score: Your shop’s reputation, including reviews and policy compliance, now plays a substantial role in your search ranking. Etsy is looking for shops that provide a seamless and positive customer experience​​.

  7. Adapting to Algorithmic Evolution: Lastly, Etsy’s algorithm is dynamic, undergoing regular updates. It's crucial to stay informed about these changes. Our blog post "How to Boost Your Etsy Store Visibility with Proven SEO Techniques" offers valuable insights into keeping your shop aligned with the latest SEO practices.

For sellers, these updates are more than just tweaks; they're signals directing how to shape your shop's future on Etsy. By paying attention to these changes and applying the strategies discussed in the guide, you can ensure your shop remains a step ahead in Etsy's digital marketplace.

6: What Strategies Can Enhance Your Shop's Performance on Etsy's Algorithm?

To stand out on Etsy, it's not just about playing the game; it's about being strategic. Here's how you can fine-tune your shop's performance in line with Etsy's algorithm:

  1. Keyword Research: Start with thorough keyword research to discover what potential customers are searching for and integrate these into your shop and listings for better visibility​​. Good news: you can download our free Long Tail Keyword Workbook. It's packed with tips to help you pick just the right words that customers are searching for. Grab your free copy and start working on your shop to fit what Etsy's looking for today.

  2. Shop Title Optimisation: Craft a clear and keyword-rich shop title. This is crucial for search rankings and attracting the right customers​.

  3. Compelling Product Titles: Create product titles that are not only keyword-focused but also clear and engaging. They should capture the essence of your product and its unique selling points​​.

  4. Detailed Product Descriptions: Write descriptions that provide valuable information and incorporate keywords without overstuffing. Highlight the benefits and features of your products to inform and persuade potential buyers​.

  5. Product Tags: Use relevant and specific keywords in your product tags. They categorise your products and enhance their search visibility​​.

  6. High-Quality Images: Invest in professional-looking photos. Good lighting and clarity can increase click-through rates and drive sales​.

  7. Positive Customer Reviews: Encourage happy customers to leave positive reviews. Excellent service leads to trust and better shop ratings, affecting your visibility on Etsy​​.

Download your free long tail keyword workbook I 6 Top Etsy Algorithm Questions Answered Insights for Shop Growth in 2024 I Your Guide Online

Don't forget to download your free long-tail keyword guide, and for a complete guide on fine-tuning these strategies for your shop, consider exploring our Etsy guide services for tailored advice.

Navigating the Etsy Algorithm for Future Success

As we've discussed, the Etsy algorithm is a dynamic force that requires continuous attention and adaptation. By engaging with the algorithm’s current preferences—be it keyword optimisation, customer service excellence, or savvy advertising—you can position your shop for greater visibility and sales. Yet, the digital marketplace is always shifting, and what works today may evolve tomorrow.

Stay informed about potential changes and be prepared to pivot your strategies as needed. Use the guides and blog posts referenced throughout this article to keep your shop ahead of the curve. Share your thoughts and questions below; let's learn from each other and thrive on Etsy together.

What questions do you have about the Etsy Algorithm? Post them in the comments below and we'll answer all your queries!


About Your Guide Online

Your Guide Online is your go-to resource for Online Business Success. We offer tailored Guides, expert blogs, and essential Toolkit resources for StartUps, Small Businesses and Freelancers.

Downloadable Online Business Guides by Your Guide Online

Want for more insights? Whether you're looking for actionable guides to ramp up your online business strategy, or resources to understand the digital trends, we've got a treasure trove of information waiting for you.

  • Explore our Comprehensive Guides on mastering SEO, social media promotion, and more. Here’s a little gift to get you started: enjoy an exclusive 10% discount off any purchase with the code: YOURGUIDE10.

  • Dive into our Resource Hub for recommendations on tools and services to boost your online business.

  • Check out our ToolKit section for practical resources like checklists and tutorials that link to the topics discussed in our blogs and guides.

  • and don't forget to check out more of our Blog for news, tutorials, how-to guides and the latest insights into digital trends.

BONUS: Subscribe free here to receive a FREE Monthly Guide to online business success, exclusive discounts, news, and tutorials! We really do give you great value at no cost!



bottom of page